Citizens Against Reckless Development
C.A.R.D.


Problem 1 is the location and size of the project:
The proposed site is located adjacent to Route 57, near the intersection of
the Mill St. Bridge.  The land is mainly zoned for agricultural use.
Click here for a map of the site
NRDC website
NRDC site proposal
Click here to see the latest rendering of the project
The shopping center entrance would be located a few hundred yards
from Agawam High School and The Agawam Public Library.  
The site is located in the middle of a residential area, bordered by
residentially zoned neighborhoods, and by Route 57.

The shopping center proposal calls for total retail space of over 563,000
square feet on a current total of 86 acres. It would be one of the largest
shopping centers in the region.

Click here to see how other shopping centers compare

The International Council of Shopping Centers (www.icsc.org) classifies
this as a
Regional Shopping Center The International Council of Shopping
Centers (www.icsc.org) classifies this as a
Regional Shopping Center

Problem 2 is the Traffic:
Although they have a portfolio of over 100 projects, consisting of over 14
million square feet, National Realty & Development Corporation (www.nrdc.com)
is unable or unwilling to give accurate traffic estimates for the proposed
shopping center.
Based on an independent traffic study using data from the Institute of
Transportation Engineers, Trip Generation, 7th Edition, a development of the
size proposed for Tennis Road would be expected to draw over 100,000 vehicle
trips per week.
Click here for the traffic figures

NRDC has proposed 3 new ramps off of Rt. 57 to access the shopping plaza. The
ramps would be subject to the approval of the Massachusetts Highway
Department. When the Rt. 57 expansion was opened in the mid 1990's,
MassHighway determined that a left turn off the Mill St. exit ramp should not be
allowed due to a 'line of sight' issue.  NRDC is proposing a left turn off that ramp
as one of their traffic improvements.  
What has changed that would result in MassHighway allowing a left turn?

Even with the ramp improvements, almost all the traffic into or out of the
shopping plaza would have to utilize Mill St.
Click here to see the ramp layout

Problem 3 is Taxes:
NRDC is claiming that there will be $900,000 in new tax benefits to the town.  
What they don't say is that will be a gross tax benefit. The net benefit will be
much less, due to the fact that large regional shopping centers have excessive
draw on town services such as police and fire, and result in increased
maintenance to roads due to the excessive traffic generated. Also, the
numerous large trucks needed to supply a large shopping center have been
proven to cause rapid deterioration to local roads.
Click here for fiscal impact studies

Problem 4 is Local Business Impact:
We are all aware of what happens when big box retailers move into
communities. The result is loss of jobs at local businesses, and in many cases,
local businesses closing.  Any new jobs created at a big box retailer are often
offset by job losses at local businesses.
New shopping centers do not create new spending, but redistribute spending,
taking business away from local merchants.
Big Box impact on local business

Problem 5 is Crime and Insurance:
The increase in crime that accompanies large shopping centers has been well
documented.  Compare the latest available crime statistics between West
Springfield and Agawam.  As the populations of the 2 towns is nearly identical,
the major difference between the 2 cities is West Springfield's major retail
areas.
Click here to see the crime comparison

Along with major traffic increases which result in numerous accidents,
shopping centers also are an attractive area for car thieves. According to the
Axia Insurance group of Springfield, MA, a new Honda Accord would cost over
$100 more to insure in West Springfield than in Agawam. How will your car
insurance costs be affected? Ask your insurance agent.


Like the thousands of people in Agawam who have contacted us, our
conclusion is that this regional shopping plaza will increase traffic, compromise
the safety of our citizens, negatively impact our tax base and property values,
hurt local business, increase our crime and insurance rates, and most of all,
result in a loss of the character and atmosphere that makes Agawam a great
place to live.

Contact your elected officials and talk to your friends and neighbors.
Let them know that

" We're not buying it ! "